Ronnie Brown had quite a fantasy day on Sunday. His four rushing TDs and one passing TD were enough to comfortably make him the top scorer for the day. The problem is, if you’re a fantasy owner and you knew what you were doing, you probably didn’t play him. Since last season, the Miami Dolphins have precisely the same number of wins as the Patriots had losses: one. That sounds like a good enough reason to send Ronnie to the pine. Sometimes the wrong decision pays off, and this is something that anyone with a little interest in the recent boom of no-limit Texas Hold’em should understand.
Ronnie’s running-mate when he was going to college at Auburn, Cadillac Williams, didn’t have such a fantastic day on Sunday. It’s looking like Williams won’t ever have another good fantasy day. Injuries have turned his career into a one-and-done. We all want to ignore guys like Cadillac, and his exclusion from consideration is a good example of the survivorship bias in sports. Players who put up solid 1000 yard, 10 touchdown rookie seasons are very commonly projected to that number or higher for the following season. Unfortunately, there are as many sophomore busts as improvements, so there isn’t much historical basis for making this extrapolation.
I made another small-sample-size mistake this week. I benched T.J. Houshmanzadeh in favor of Bryant Johnson due to Housh’s complete lack of productivity over the first two weeks, and Bryant’s favorable match-up. The Detroit defense was as soft as I expected it to be, but Johnson wasn’t involved in the early shellacking, and after that Mike Martz toned down his offense, effectively killing Johnson’s chance to make a meaningful impact on the box score. That’s fantasy sports for you. On the other hand, Housh was involved heavily in a downright fiesty effort by Cincinatti to get their first win of the season. An overtime field goal ended that effort after Housh had outscored Johnson by 18 points. Luckily, I was saved from my bonehead decision by the Cowboys offense and scaped a victory out. Here’s to not learning my lesson!